Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita released the following press release on December 19, 2024.
Driving away deceptive conduct in the used car industry, Attorney General Todd Rokita files six lawsuits on behalf of buyers
Attorney General Todd Rokita has announced a sweep of lawsuits against multiple Indiana car dealers allegedly engaged in deceptive acts against car-buying Hoosiers. The lawsuits focus on helping affected consumers who purchased used cars and allegedly ended up with a variety of broken promises, such as not receiving titles or receiving vehicles with salvage titles that were not legal to drive on Indiana roads.
“Indiana consumers deserve to get what they pay for,” Attorney General Rokita said. “We won’t hesitate to bring lawsuits against car dealers who lie or fail to honor their end of agreements with purchasers. Deceptive conduct hurts consumers, and it hurts the reputation of the vast majority of Indiana car dealers who conduct business the right way.”
The lawsuits were filed against Cars R Us, MG Motors, Merliot Auto Sales, Phoenix Motors, Redelman’s Deals on Wheels, and W. Main Auto Sales.
MG Motors and W. Main Auto Sales each allegedly sold cars to consumers and failed to deliver titles. MG Motors allegedly failed to deliver 17 titles while W. Main Auto sales allegedly failed to deliver 22 titles.
Merliot Auto Sales allegedly sold 17 vehicles that had “salvage” title brands to unknowing consumers. Vehicles with “salvage” title brands cannot legally be driven on Indiana roads.
Cars R Us allegedly agreed as part of a vehicle sale to pay off the loan on the consumer’s trade-in vehicle. Cars R Us allegedly failed to make the trade-in payoff, leaving the consumer with multiple auto loans — one on their trade-in and one on their newly-purchased vehicle.
Phoenix Motors sold vehicles to two consumers when the vehicles were allegedly not owned by Phoenix Motors. The vehicles were allegedly then taken back by Phoenix and returned to their original owners, despite the consumers paying for the vehicles in full — leaving the consumers without the monies they paid or the vehicles they purchased.
Redelman’s Deals on Wheels lost its Indiana dealer license to sell vehicles in December 2023. Redelmen’s allegedly continued to sell cars without the required license.
Attorney General Rokita is seeking injunctive relief, consumer restitution, civil penalties, and costs in the lawsuits.
Consumers who believe they have encountered wrongful business practices are encouraged to file complaints with the Attorney General at www.in.gov/attorneygeneral.
The lawsuit that was filed against Redelman’s Deals on Wheels and Emilie Redelman can be found by using this link: Legal Filing
*End of Official Press Release*
After receiving this press release, the WTRE news team did more research on local dealer Redelman’s Deals on Wheels and found that the dealership was fined and received many administrative actions from the Indiana Secretary of State Diego Morales Auto Dealer Services Division including:
9/7/2022 Fine Order Fine Order
4/26/2023 Consent Agreement for 9/7/23 Fine Order Consent Agreement
5/22/2023 Fine Order Fine Order
12/4/2023 License Revocation Order License Revocation Order
12/11/2023 Fine Order Fine Order
12/11/2023 License Denial Order License Denial Order
12/18/2023 Fine Order Fine Order
9/23/2024 Final Order Final Order
According to the September 23, 2024, final order it states in the Final Administrative Decision section “The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Vanessa Voigt Gould, having heard the evidence and arguments presented in this matter, now issues this Final Order addressing the decision by the Indiana Secretary of State Auto Services Division (SOS) to assess a total of $1,250.00 in fines, revoke Redelman’s Deals on Wheels, LLC’s (Redelman’s) dealer license #2000205, revoke Emilie Redelman’s dealer license #1900268, and bar her from ever applying for, obtaining, or operating as a dealer, dealer manager, or having similar status or performing similar functions as a dealer, or be directly or indirectly in employ of a dealer in the State of Indiana. This decision favorable to the SOS with the assessed fines modified to $1,000.00.”
